04.15.05
Bear Flag League Weighs in on Apple Subpoena Case
80 CALIFORNIA BLOGGERS
WEIGH IN ON APPLE SUBPOENA CASE
Irvine, CA. April 15, 2005. Today, the Bear Flag League — a coalition of 80 bloggers who are current and former California residents — filed a friend of the court brief with the California Sixth District Court of Appeal in O’Grady v. Superior Court. The O’Grady case is an appellate proceeding arising from a lawsuit filed by Apple Computer in Santa Clara County in December 2004. Apple sued unnamed individuals who are accused of leaking information regarding Apple’s new products to several news websites. Apple has initiated discovery procedures available under California law to identify the source of the leaked information, including serving a subpoena to the Internet service provider for one of the news websites. Apple hopes that the subpoena will reveal the identity of its employees or other parties involved in the leaks. The publishers of the news websites have asked the Santa Clara County Superior Court to block Apple’s discovery in order to protect the publishers’ confidential sources. When the Superior Court denied that request, the publishers filed a petition with the Sixth District Court of Appeal. The lawsuit involves the competing interests of the First Amendment guarantees of a free press on the one hand and Apple’s rights to protect the unlawful dissemination of its trade secrets on the other.
The Bear Flag League is an unincorporated association of current and former residents of the State of California who operate and/or contribute to 80 blogs. The League was formed in July 2003 in order to collaborate and publish articles concerning California culture, current events, legal issues and politics for the reading public.
The brief filed by the League today urges the Sixth District Court of Appeal to afford these website publishers and all bloggers the same privileges and protection from discovery that traditional print and broadcast journalists enjoy under the United States and California Constitution. Because these website publishers targeted by Apple are engaged in the same news gathering and reporting activities as print journalists, broadcast reporters and Internet bloggers, they have the right to protect their confidential sources and thereby maintain a strong, independent and free press.
The League’s brief was prepared by a number of the League’s lawyer members, including, Justene Adamec of PUMILIA & ADAMEC LLP and Jeffrey Lewis and Benjamin P. Pugh of Enterprise Counsel Group, ALC, whose contact information is below.
The League’s brief was prepared by a number of the League’s lawyer members, including, Justene Adamec of PUMILIA & ADAMEC LLP and Jeffrey Lewis and Benjamin P. Pugh of Enterprise Counsel Group, ALC, whose contact information is below.
A copy of the League’s brief may be downloaded here.
The League’s homepage is located at www.BearFlagLeague.com.
Justene Adamec
PUMILIA & ADAMEC LLP
555 W 5th St Ste 3100
Los Angeles, CA 90013-1010
Tel. (213) 622-3006
Fax. (213) 622-3006
Jeffrey Lewis
Benjamin P. Pugh
ENTERPRISE COUNSEL GROUP, ALC
Five Park Plaza, Suite 450
Irvine, California 92614
Tel. (949) 833-8550
Fax. (949) 833-8540
# # #
Diggers Realm said,
April 26, 2005 at 5:59 pm
Bear Flag League Files Court Brief Arguing Bloggers Should Receive Journalist Status Under The Law
The Bear Flag League — of which Diggers Realm is a part of — has filed a court brief arguing that bloggers who report on the news should also be classified as journalists under the law and should therefore receive…